DIY Dog Kennel vs Pre-Made: Pros and Cons

Introduction

Building or buying a dog kennel is more than a home improvement decision—it’s about creating a safe, comfortable, and happy space for your pup. And one of the first questions pet parents face is: Should I build a dog kennel myself or buy a pre-made one?

The answer depends on a few factors like budget, skills, time, and how specific your dog’s needs are. Some owners enjoy rolling up their sleeves and customizing every detail with a DIY approach. Others prefer the ease and speed of clicking “add to cart” and getting a professional kennel delivered to their door.

This guide will walk you through the pros and cons of each approach so you can make an informed choice. Whether you're handy with tools or looking for a reliable shortcut, we’ve got you covered. And if you're leaning toward ready-made, check out the variety of premium dog kennels available at PetsGear for inspiration.

The Rise of DIY Dog Kennels

With the rise of Pinterest, YouTube tutorials, and budget-conscious living, DIY dog kennels have become more popular than ever. Many pet owners enjoy the process of creating something with their own hands—especially when it benefits their furry friend. Plus, it gives you the chance to fully customize every aspect from size and shape to materials and interior layout.

DIY projects can range from basic pallet wood builds to fully insulated, barn-style kennels with porches and sunshades. If you already have tools lying around, the materials can be surprisingly affordable. For others, it's the creative process and satisfaction that make the extra effort worthwhile.

But before you grab your drill and hammer, there are some things to consider—especially when it comes to safety, comfort, and longevity. Let’s break down both sides of the fence.

Pros of Building Your Own Dog Kennel

Going the DIY route has its perks, especially if you’re confident with tools and have a clear vision for your pup’s palace. Here are the biggest benefits:

Customization and Creativity

This is probably the biggest draw of building your own kennel. You can design it exactly how you (and your dog) want it:

• Size it perfectly to fit a corner of your yard or home

• Choose materials that match your exterior or interior design

• Add unique features like storage, windows, or raised decks

For pet parents with specific needs—like dogs with anxiety, large breeds, or multiple pets—this freedom is invaluable.

Budget-Friendly Options

If you’ve already got basic tools like a drill, saw, and measuring tape, building your own kennel can be much cheaper than buying a pre-made model—especially a high-end one. Materials like treated pine, plywood, or repurposed pallets are affordable and widely available. You can also pick up roofing, insulation, or paint based on your budget and climate needs.

Here’s a quick comparison of potential DIY costs:

Total: Around $150–$400 depending on size and finish

Compare that to pre-made insulated models that range from $200–$600 or more, and you can see why DIY appeals to budget-savvy owners.

Bonding Experience and Personal Satisfaction

Let’s be honest—there’s something deeply satisfying about building a structure with your own two hands, especially for a beloved pet. It can be a fun weekend project and even an opportunity to get the family involved. You’ll feel a sense of pride watching your dog relax in something you created.

And your dog? They’ll feel your scent in the materials and notice the time you spent getting everything just right. It adds a layer of emotional value that store-bought kennels just can’t match.

Cons of DIY Dog Kennels

Despite the charm and cost-saving potential, building your own dog kennel isn’t always the best option—especially if you’re short on time, tools, or experience.

Time Commitment and Skill Requirement

Let’s be real: building a dog kennel can be time-consuming. Between planning, shopping for materials, cutting, assembling, sealing, and finishing—it can take days, even weeks if you're working in your spare time.

And if you're not handy, things can get frustrating fast. Misaligned panels, unsafe joins, or poor ventilation might compromise your dog’s comfort or even safety.

DIY is best for those who have basic carpentry experience or at least feel confident following step-by-step plans.

Safety Concerns and Material Quality

Store-bought kennels go through quality checks and safety testing. DIY kennels? Not so much. If the build isn’t solid or the materials aren’t safe (think treated wood that’s toxic when chewed), your dog could be at risk.

• Avoid using pressure-treated wood unless it’s sealed

• Ensure no exposed nails, screws, or sharp edges

• Provide proper ventilation and waterproofing

Without careful planning, it’s easy to miss crucial elements like weather resistance, insulation, and secure locks—which could lead to discomfort or injury.

Lack of Professional Finish or Durability

Even a well-built DIY kennel might not hold up like a professionally manufactured one. Pre-made kennels often use CNC machines and weather-tested materials that last for years. In contrast, DIY builds can start to degrade quickly if not sealed properly or exposed to harsh weather.

If you want a kennel that can stand up to the elements or last through multiple dogs, DIY might not be the most durable route unless you’re very experienced with outdoor carpentry.

Pros of Pre-Made Dog Kennels

Pre-made kennels have come a long way. Today’s market offers everything from simple plastic crates to luxury insulated dog houses with decks and windows. If convenience and reliability are your priorities, here’s why buying pre-made might be the smarter move.

Time-Saving and Convenience

This is a big one—especially for busy pet parents. Pre-made kennels arrive ready to go or require only basic assembly. That means:

• No trips to the hardware store

• No measuring or cutting wood

• No worrying about tools or plans

You can literally go from unboxing to your dog enjoying their new space in under an hour in many cases. For people who work full-time or simply want a quick solution, pre-made is hard to beat.

Safety Standards and Tested Designs

Reputable kennel brands test their products for safety, durability, and weather resistance. You can rest easy knowing your kennel won’t fall apart during a storm or pose hazards like splinters or exposed nails.

Look for certifications or features like:

• Non-toxic, chew-safe materials

• Proper ventilation systems

• Waterproofing and UV protection

• Secure latches and door flaps

Most of these features are built-in, so you don’t have to worry about DIY add-ons or fixes after the fact.

Range of Sizes and Features Available

Whether you need a cozy crate for a tiny pup or a weatherproof palace for your Great Dane, there’s a kennel out there for you. Pre-made options include:

• Insulated winter kennels

• Portable travel crates

• Indoor wood and metal designs

• Multi-dog enclosures

You also get design options—modern, rustic, minimalist—so you can match the kennel to your home or garden.

Cons of Pre-Made Kennels

While the ease and safety of pre-made kennels are attractive, they do have some limitations.

Limited Customization

The biggest downside is that you’re locked into whatever the manufacturer offers. While some models come in different sizes or colors, you can’t change the shape, add custom features, or resize compartments unless you’re handy enough to modify them post-purchase.

For pet parents with unique needs—like fitting the kennel into a non-standard space or accommodating a special-needs dog—this lack of flexibility can be a deal-breaker.

Higher Upfront Cost

Pre-made kennels—especially insulated or designer models—can get expensive fast. Quality outdoor wooden kennels often start at $200 and go up to $600+ depending on the features and size.

You’re paying for convenience, quality assurance, and often, the brand name. While it's usually worth it long-term, the upfront cost can be a barrier if you're on a tight budget.

Assembly May Still Be Required

Don’t be fooled by the term “pre-made”—many of these products still require partial assembly. You may need tools like a screwdriver or drill, and some instructions aren’t always as clear as they should be. If you’re expecting to just set it and forget it, you might be disappointed.

Comparing Costs: DIY vs Pre-Made

Let’s break down the numbers so you can see where your money goes with each approach.

Bottom line?

• DIY is better if you’re handy, want full control, and have time.

• Pre-made is better if you value time, safety, and a polished finish.

Which Option Is Best for Your Dog?

The final decision between a DIY dog kennel and a pre-made model should revolve around what’s best for your dog—not just what’s easiest or cheapest for you. Every dog is unique, and their living space should reflect their needs, not just your DIY skills or shopping habits.

Consider Your Dog’s Personality and Needs

• Active dogs may benefit from larger, more open designs, which can be harder to achieve with pre-made kennels unless you go premium.

• Anxious or timid dogs prefer cozy, enclosed spaces. Both DIY and pre-made kennels can offer this, but a custom build allows for unique comfort features.

• Senior dogs may need low-entry points or orthopedic flooring—again, these are easier to implement in DIY designs or higher-end pre-mades.

Evaluate Your Environment

Live in a cold or wet area? A pre-made kennel with verified weatherproofing is a smart choice. Live in a milder climate with space to work? A DIY kennel could be fun and practical.

Also think about:

• Yard or indoor space

• Local weather

• How often your dog will use the kennel (daily, travel, temporary)

Match your decision to your dog’s lifestyle. That’s where you’ll find the best fit.

Common Mistakes to Avoid with Either Option

No matter which route you take, there are a few pitfalls you’ll want to steer clear of:

1. Misjudging Size

Always measure your dog and leave room for growth or accessories. Too small is uncomfortable, but too large won’t retain heat well.

2. Overlooking Ventilation

Even in winter, dogs need airflow. Poor ventilation can cause overheating or respiratory issues—whether it's a DIY kennel or store-bought.

3. Ignoring Insulation

Especially for outdoor kennels, proper insulation is non-negotiable. Don’t assume that wood alone will keep your dog warm enough.

4. Choosing Price Over Quality

We get it—budget matters. But cutting corners on materials or choosing the cheapest pre-made option can end up costing more in vet bills or replacements.

5. Forgetting Maintenance

Even the best kennel won’t last without upkeep. Clean regularly, check for damage, and make seasonal adjustments (like adding insulation or shade).

Tips for Enhancing Any Kennel (DIY or Pre-Made)

No matter which type of kennel you choose, these add-ons can boost comfort, safety, and longevity:

• Weatherproof coating or sealant

• Chew-proof mats or thermal bedding

• Removable or adjustable floors for easy cleaning

• Insulated door flaps or plastic covers

• Personalized touches like name tags, colors, or custom ramps

Making the space feel like a little home helps your dog feel secure and happy inside. That’s what really matters.

Final Thoughts

At the end of the day, the choice between a DIY or pre-made dog kennel boils down to your lifestyle, budget, and your dog’s needs. Both paths have their strengths: DIY gives you complete creative control and potential cost savings, while pre-made kennels offer convenience, safety, and polished quality.

If you’re crafty and love a weekend project, go ahead and build your dream kennel. But if you're short on time or want peace of mind from a professionally-tested design, pre-made is a worthy investment.

And if you’re leaning toward the latter, be sure to browse the wide range of dog kennels available at PetsGear—trusted by Aussie pet parents who want quality and comfort for their four-legged mates.

FAQs

1. Is it cheaper to build your own dog kennel?
Yes—if you already have tools and use affordable materials. However, unexpected costs or errors can make DIY more expensive than expected.

2. Are pre-made dog kennels better for outdoor use?
Generally, yes. They often come weatherproofed, insulated, and built with tested materials for long-term durability.

3. What materials should I avoid in a DIY kennel?
Avoid pressure-treated wood unless it's sealed, and never use materials that splinter easily or contain chemicals harmful to pets.

4. Can I customize a pre-made kennel after buying it?
Yes, but only to a certain extent. You can add paint, covers, or accessories, but structural changes can be difficult or void warranties.

5. How long does it take to build a DIY dog kennel?
Anywhere from 8 to 20 hours depending on the complexity, materials, and your experience with tools.